• 318 pages
  • 6 x 9
  • Price: $33.95
  • EAN: 9781439912775
  • Publication: Jan 2016
  • Price: $95.50
  • EAN: 9781439912768
  • Publication: Jan 2016
  • Price: $33.95
  • EAN: 9781439912782
  • Publication: Jan 2016

The Muslim Question in Europe

Political Controversies and Public Philosophies

Peter O'Brien

An estimated twenty million Muslims now reside in Europe, mostly as a result of large-scale postwar immigration. In The Muslim Question in Europe, Peter O’Brien challenges the popular notion that the hostilities concerning immigration—which continues to provoke debates about citizenship, headscarves, secularism, and terrorism—are a clash between “Islam and the West.” Rather, he explains, the vehement controversies surrounding European Muslims are better understood as persistent, unresolved intra-European tensions.

O’Brien contends that the best way to understand the politics of state accommodation of European Muslims is through the lens of three competing political ideologies: liberalism, nationalism, and postmodernism. These three broadly understood philosophical traditions represent the most influential normative forces in the politics of immigration in Europe today. He concludes that Muslim Europeans do not represent a monolithic anti-Western bloc within Europe. Although they vehemently disagree among themselves, it is along the same basic liberal, nationalist, and postmodern contours as non-Muslim Europeans.


"Peter O’Brien discusses the huge amount of research on the major controversies surrounding Islam and Muslims in Europe when it comes to secularism, women’s rights, citizenship, and terrorism. He shows how and why these controversies reveal the inherent contradictions and dilemmas of European identities as much as they shed light on the so called ‘exceptionalism’ of Islam. The Muslim Question in Europe will be very relevant to students and scholars of religion, comparative politics, and immigration."
Jocelyne Cesari, Professor of Religion and Politics, University of Birmingham; Director of the Islam in the West Program at Harvard University; and author of The Awakening of Muslim Democracy

"Reflecting a stunningly broad range of erudition resulting from decades of research, The Muslim Question in Europe provides an antidote for those grappling to understand the myriad migration-related challenges faced by Europeans. O’Brien contends that the complexities are best explicated by viewing the issues through a Kulturkampf lens pitting liberal, nationalist, and post-modernist insights against or complementary to one another. Of special interest is the timely chapter on terrorism and security. Here, too, he discerns a pattern of normative Kulturkampf and policy messiness. He views this outcome as very European. Islam, after all, is of Europe too."
Mark J. Miller, University of Delaware and co-author of The Age of Migration

"A thought-provoking and fresh look at the history of ideas that have shaped Europeans’ encounter with the historic settlement of Muslim minorities in Western Europe. O’Brien is an able guide to the best research in philosophy and the social sciences as he explores the nuances of western cultural contexts. The Muslim Question in Europe combines rich normative and empirical analyses that shed light on unresolved conflicts in European nation-states."
Jonathan Laurence, Associate Professor of Political Science at Boston College and author of The Emancipation of Europe’s Muslims and Integrating Islam

"(A) remarkable book.... Without taking a stand himself (and denying any claims to absolute certainty), the author focuses, in turn, on citizenship, the headscarf controversy, secularism, and domestic security/terrorism."
The Muslim World Book Review

"O’Brien wonders to what extent the presence of Muslim communities in Europe makes explicit, or complicates, broader philosophical commitments held by European political actors. He concludes that by examining 'the Muslim question' we can see how fragments of several political philosophical positions are assembled by political actors addressing the practical challenges of living with diversity.... O'Brien’s text illuminates the dialectic between philosophical commitments and practical political engagement, making a compelling case that his approach is more useful than purely abstract discussion about, say, how liberal principles should be applied in a specific case."
The Journal of Race, Ethnicity, and Politics

"(A) remarkable book.... Without taking a stand himself (and denying any claims to absolute certainty), the author focuses, in turn, on citizenship, the headscarf controversy, secularism, and domestic security/terrorism."
Journal of Islamic Studies

About the Author(s)

Peter O’Brien is Professor of Political Science at Trinity University in San Antonio, Texas. He is the author of European Perceptions of Islam and America from Saladin to George W. Bush: Europe’s Fragile Ego Uncovered, and Beyond the Swastika. He has been a Social Science Research Council Fellow at the Free University in Berlin, and Fulbright Visiting Professor at Boğaziçi University in Istanbul and at the Humboldt University in Berlin.