People, Planning, Preservation, and Urban Renewal, 1915-2020Dennis E. Gale
The origins of gentrification date back to World War I—only it was sometimes known as “remodeling” then. Dennis Gale’s insightful book, The Misunderstood History of Gentrification, provides a recontextualization of American gentrification, planning, and policymaking. He argues that gentrification must be understood as an urban phenomenon with historical roots in the very early twentieth century.
Gale uses solid empirical evidence to trace the embryonic revitalization of Georgetown, Greenwich Village, Beacon Hill, and elsewhere back to 1915. He shows how reinvestment and restoration reversed urban decline and revitalized neighborhoods. The Misunderstood History of Gentrification also explains how federal policies such as the Urban Redevelopment Program (later named Urban Renewal), which first emerged in 1949, razed urban slums and created an “urban crisis” that persisted in the 1960s and ‘70s. This situation soon prompted city gentrifiers and historic preservationists to reuse and rehabilitate existing structures.
Within a more expansive historical framework, Gale offers a fresh perspective on and debunks misperceptions about gentrification in America.
“ Scholarly literature on gentrification has exploded, but very little attention has been devoted to the phenomenon’s origin. Using archival records, Gale shows that gentrification’s origins date back to the 1910s and 1920s, not the 1960s and 1970s as is usually thought. He shows that the rise of the historic preservation movement contributed to the demise of Urban Renewal, thereby stimulating today’s advanced gentrification affecting cities across America. Gale’s critique of current discourse on gentrification is right on target. The term ‘gentrification’ has been so broadly defined that it is virtually useless. The debate has focused on displacement while ignoring the benefits of a strengthened tax base and the preservation of older historic housing. Gentrifiers—many of whom want to promote social justice—have been unfairly demonized. This book should be read by policymakers, scholars, students, and laypeople. Working together, they can shape an inner city characterized by stable and income- and racially-mixed communities that benefit all residents.”
—David P. Varady, Emeritus Professor in the School of Planning at the University of Cincinnati
"The Misunderstood History of Gentrification is a critically important addition to the burgeoning literature on the subject. With his broad scholarly vision, Gale delivers on his promise of providing a prologue to contemporary gentrification studies and, in so doing, challenges us to view public post-WWII urban revitalization efforts anew."
—The Journal of Urban Affairs
" Gale offers an intriguing analysis of a previously unrecognized chapter in the history of urban gentrification.... Summing Up: Highly recommended."
" (A) valuable historical perspective on American gentrification, something that, thus far, has been lacking.... This highly readable, politically neutral book represents an important contribution to the neighborhood revitalization literature."
—The Journal of the American Planning Association
"Gale contends that gentrification as a process of neighborhood change first occurred in older northeastern city neighborhoods as early as the 1910s and 1920s.... Three in-depth case studies anchor the book’s central thesis.... Rich in historical detail and analysis, these studies effectively chronicle the transformation of the highlighted neighborhoods while presenting a persuasive case for reconsidering the origin and parameters of gentrification."
"Gale provokes a much-needed re-examination of gentrification.... (He) offers compelling evidence that gentrification began much earlier and with a greater variety of motivations and outcomes than are generally recognized.... Urban planners, activists, and those interested in urban issues will find that these case studies and subsequent discussion amplify the current understanding of gentrification and its role in urban revitalization."
—History: Review of New Books