FSA Photography ReconsideredJames Curtis
In May 1936, Farm Security Administration photographer Arthur Rothstein was sent to the Badlands of South Dakota to document the persistent drought that ravaged the Great Plains. He came upon a sun-bleached steer’s skull on a parched alkali flat and took several photographs of the scene. Then he moved the skull a few feet to achieve more dramatic contrast and deeper shadow detail. It was this photo that would rank among Rothstein’s most famous images, but when the story of his artistic manipulation was discovered by the press, the resulting outrage and charges of fakery threatened to shut down the FSA’s documentary project. Rothstein spent the rest of his career explaining the skull photographs.
In Mind’s Eye, Mind’s Truth, James Curtis challenges the pervasive belief that documentary photographs are realistic because they are not consciously arranged images. The 82 photographs considered in this book evidence the deliberate arrangement of elements and subjects that are the hallmarks of art and, as such, are forbidden to documentary photographers. Curtis argues that this "manipulation" was not intended to deceive but to persuade. Roy Stryker, who headed the FSA documentary project, and his photographers wanted to enlist the sympathies of an urban, middle-class audience in the cause of reform and so they fashioned images that conformed to the values of their viewers. Thus, the bitter realism portrayed in the FSA collection was "deliberate, calculated, and highly stylized."
Curtis focuses his analysis on four well-known FSA staff photographers whose work gained widespread recognition and did much to influence America’s vision of rural poverty. In considering revered and unknown photographs by Walker Evans, Dorothea Lange, Russell Tee, and Arthur Rothstein, as well as personal papers, memoirs, interviews, and the FSA file, Curtis reconstructs the methods the photographers used to create the images that defined the Depression in the public’s imagination.
"(Curtis) challenges the conventional belief that documentary photographs are realistic because they are not consciously arranged images."
—Reviews in American History
"Curtis' brilliant, revolutionary study of 82 photos probes a central paradox: documentary photography at times derives its power from artful manipulation."
"Curtis offers provocative readings of the FSA's most famous pictures...never less than absorbing."
—The Philadelphia Inquirer
"By looking closely at the pictures and the visual culture of which they were a part, Curtis finds evidence that ‘documentary’ did not necessarily—or even generally—mean ‘real’ or ‘true’: more often, the documentary photograph documented the values, prejudices, beliefs, and hopes of the people pointing the cameras, and the audience they wished to reach. In the process of seeing the photography of the 1930s from behind the lens, Curtis proves that documents of material culture, when interpreted with respect for their own conventions and codes of meaning, can fundamentally alter our understanding of history. Mind’s Eye, Mind’s Truth opens our eyes to a brand new New Deal era."
—Karal Ann Marling, Professor of Art History and American Studies, University of Minnesota
"An outstanding contribution to a subject much written-about and yet as Curtis demonstrates, much misunderstood Mind’s Eye, Mind’s Truth is one of the most brilliant analyses of how to use photographs as evidence for cultural history I have ever read. This book will make a major contribution to our understanding of FSA photography and what it says about the ways Americans in the 1930s tried to make sense of their own society. Curtis’ pioneering techniques of analysis are sure to influence all who attempt to use documentary photographs to explain historical events."
—David Culbert, Professor of History, Louisiana State University