Expected Miracles

Surgeons at Work

Joan Cassell
Book Cover

PB: $34.95
EAN: 978-0-87722-838-7
Publication: Jun 91

Ebook: $34.95
EAN: 978-1-4399-0528-9

259 pages
5.25 x 8.5

The world of surgeons from their own perspective


Expected Miracles explores the world of surgeons from their own perspective—how they perceive themselves, their work, colleagues, and communities. Recognizing that surgery is an art, a craft, a science, and a business, Joan Cassell offers, through poignant, painful, and thrilling descriptions, a vivid portrayal of the culture of surgery.

Cassell has entered a realm where laypersons are usually horizontal, naked, and anesthetized. Using the central metaphor of the surgical "miracle," she illuminates the drama of the operating room, where surgeons and patients alike expect heroic performance. She takes us backstage to overhear conversations about patients, families, and colleagues, observe operations, eavesdrop on gossip about surgeons’ performances, and examine the values, behavior, and misbehavior of surgeons at work.

Said one Chief of Surgery, "You couldn’t have a good surgeon who didn’t believe in the concept of the Hero." Following this lead, Cassell explores the heroic temperament of those who perform surgical "miracles" and finds that the demands and pressures of surgical practice require traits that in other fields, or in personal interactions, are often regarded as undesirable. She observes, "surgeons must tread a fine line between courage and recklessness, confidence and hubris, a positive attitude and a magical one." This delicate balance and frequent imbalance is portrayed through several character sketches. She contrasts the caring attention and technical mastery of The Exemplary Surgeon with the theatrical posturing of The Prima Donna and the slick showiness and questionable morals of The Sleazy Surgeon.

She also identifies the attributes that surgeons admire in each other. They believe that only peers can really evaluate each other, and, while doctors might not speak negatively about colleagues in public, the community of surgeons exerts considerable pressure on its members to perform competently.

Unlike "doctor-bashing" chronicles, Expected Miracles seeks to understand the charismatic authority of surgeons, its instability, and its price-to surgeons and to patients.


"Joan Cassell's book is fair-minded and unsparing. A meticulous dissection of The Surgeon by an observer whose gaze is as sharp and precise as a scalpel. For me there was a shock of recognition on every page." Richard Selzer, M.D., Yale Medical School (retired), and author of Mortal Lessons: Notes on the Art of Surgery and Letters to a Young Doctor

"The most explicit account I have read about what surgeons do; what their experiences are like; what they are like; what they think about their successes and failures; and what an astonishing variety of experiences of being a surgeon there are. Written with great clarity and considerable grace.... I hope this book will become assigned reading for surgeons, surgical residents, medical students with interest in surgery, surgical nurses and technicians, and anyone who has to undergo a surgical procedure. A fine achievement." Arthur Kleinman, M.D., Ph.D., Department of Social Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Department of Anthropology, Harvard University

"Joan Cassell gives us valuable insight into the mores, the high professional standards—as well as the lapse in and abuse of these standards—and the 'esprit de corps' of the 'fellowship of surgeons.' And she demonstrates that... this sub-profession does indeed form a Fellowship whose culture it is important for every prospective patient to understand." James W. Fernandez, Professor of Anthropology, University of Chicago

Table of Contents

Cast of Characters Preface: Some Words for Social Scientists Acknowledgments Introduction: The Surgical "Miracle"

1. The Art, Craft, and Science of Miracles The Good Surgeon: Colleagues' Evaluations • Looking Upward from the Table: A Patient's-Eye View • Caring and Healing • Can a Bad Person Be a Good Surgeon?

2. The Temperament of Surgeons "Be Ballsy: Do It!" • Surgery as Ritual Drama • The Price: The "Paranoia" of Surgeons • The Price for Patients

3. The Fellowship of Surgeons The Fellowship • Informal Learning during Training • The Morality Play

4. Costing Out Miracles: The Business of Surgery Three Surgeons in Private Practice • An Exemplary Surgeon in a Prepaid Health Plan • "Full-Time" Men

5. A Day with a Compassionate Young Surgeon The Day • The Burden

6. Let's Go for It!

7. Deadly Surgical Sins Vices of Excess • Generative Sins • Defects, or Character Flaws • Deficiencies • Judging Sins

8. It's No Fun Anymore Fun and War Games • No Fun • "The Disenchantment of the World" • The Bureaucratization of Charisma • The Erosion of Charisma • Horror Stories: The Patient as Enemy

9. Expected Miracles What of Patients? • Expecting Miracles

Coda: The Research Process Beginnings • Access Refused • Entrée • Sample and Methods

Notes Glossary Bibliography Index